Outside loudspeakers from places of worship in India should be banned

Loudspeakers

I read a story in Indian Express newspaper today, which talks about communal tension in a village in Western Uttar Pradesh, India because of loudspeakers from a temple.

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/politics/up-bjp-calls-mahapanchayat-against-removal-of-loudspeaker-from-temple/

I am aware of several such examples in India over the years. It is not just one off.

If you think about it, and use logic, you will start questioning the use of loudspeakers from such places. Why do we need loudspeakers from any place of worship? One of my friends , Ravi Bhatia, made a light-hearted, but brilliant, comment in my Facebook wall saying, “agreed. God is not deaf”. Another friend, Yogi Chouhan, made a very reflective comment that “God is usually found in silence”.

Outside use of loudspeakers is not needed because,

1. it can cause, and has caused, communal troubles in the past,

2. it also causes sound pollution,

3. it disturbs sleep and consequent harming of physical health of people,

4. it causes hearing damage,

4. it become a real nuisance to students during their exam times.

I remember vividly how I was disturbed by blaring sound of a Devi Jagran Jagrata (overnight singing of religious songs) and loud sound of Aazans from nearby mosques when I was in India.

Devotees of any religion do not need reminders from loudspeakers. If they are true followers of their religions, they will remember when to go to their temples or mosques. They will remember what they have to do as part of their religion. Religion is a private matter between us and our God, and it should remain this way!

Just in case you do not know, no Western country allows use of loudspeakers in the manner it is in India!

Why do people who are not from a particular religion need to be forced to hear the religious sounds and sermons from that religion?

Places of worship can use loudspeakers inside the premises (if needed), but not outside.

Indian Govt should ban them for outside use and enforce the ban effectively and without any exception,  favour, bias or discrimination.

Let this become a part of new India, which practises true secularism, not only in spirit but also in letters!

Let this become part of “Achchhe Din” (Good days) for India!

Dr Yadu Singh/Sydney/3rd July, 2014

http://www.facebook.com/dryadusingh

http://www.twitter.com/dryadusingh

2 thoughts on “Outside loudspeakers from places of worship in India should be banned

  1. Good idea, but I don’t think it will work…..We are creatures of habits and one of them is loud music, sermons, kirtans. bhajans etc.,…..That is the Hindu part:

    How about the DAILY early morn loudspeakers of mullahs conveying their message from Allah, or a prophet nobody has seen, or known  for HIS spirituality…… AND WHICH WAKES UIP ENTIRE NEIGHBOURHOODS OF NONE MUSLIMS? 

    ANY PROTECTION FROM THAT FOR THE MASSES???

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s